A Rookie Teacher Responds to Critical Feedback

          In this Mathematics Teacher article, Georgia middle-school teacher Corey Gray describes getting some blunt feedback from his principal in October of his first year. Gray thought he had taught an excellent lesson as the principal sat with her laptop at the back of the room: a clear explanation of the distributive property, students turning and talking about their strategies, then using manipulatives. But when Gray nervously took a seat in the principal’s office that afternoon, she said, “You are an amazing math teacher. However, your expectations for a one-size-fits-all type of perfection leads to your own frustration in the classroom and clouds your vision of your students’ mathematical genius.” She used the analogy of trying to put square pegs into round holes. 

          Gray was taken aback but soon realized the principal was right. His very structured classroom management and one-right-answer approach to math procedures “was creating an environment riddled with fear and fraught with comparison,” he says. “I asked for answers, rather than asking for pathways to solutions. I confirmed correct answers only, rather than affirming thinking and productive struggle. I did not take the time to truly understand, appreciate, and value my students for who they were…” Students were doing math rather than thinking about math, resulting in disappointing and inequitable outcomes. Gray’s takeaway from the conversation boiled down to three lessons: 

•  Know that you are on a journey. “This journey is not easy,” he says, “but it is necessary to develop our teaching abilities and character… Embracing this truth allows you to welcome and seek out community…” 
• No one knows everything, but surround yourself with educators who know a lot. Collectively, you and your fellow teachers need to take risks, seek out the best methods and materials, and figure out what works best for which students. 
• Don’t let perfection be the enemy of the good. “For me,” says Gray, “my desire to create the perfect educational environment for my students, anchored in problem-solving and student choice, fuels me, but at times it can become a burden because I often feel alone and burnt out… I remind myself daily to give myself grace, as I am not alone in this quest.” 

 “Teaching Is a Journey: Square Pegs, Round Holes” by Corey Gray in Mathematics Teacher: Learning & Teaching PK-12, July 2024 (Vol. 117, #7, pp. 530-532); Gray can be reached at corey.gray@uga.edu.

Please Note: This summary is reprinted with permission from issue #1046 of The Marshall Memo, an excellent resource for educators.